AI can draft the checklist, agents still protect the outcome
Inventory765,048▲ 22,042
30-yr Fixed Rate30-yr Fixed6.39%▲ 0.00%
Inventory765,048▲ 22,042
30-yr Fixed Rate30-yr Fixed6.39%▲ 0.00%
- Sign In
- Subscribe
- [](https://www.housingwire.com/?s=)
*
- Your Account
- Manage Feed
- Subscription Options
- Newsletters
- Gift HousingWire
- Podcasts
- Company Search
- Logout
- News
- Latest News
- Housing Market Tracker
- Housing Market
- Mortgage
- Mortgage Rates
- Homebuilding
- Reverse
- Real Estate
- Agents
- Brokerage
- Technology
- Title
- Vetted
- IntelligenceNEW
- Events
- The Gathering
- AI Summit
- Mortgage Banking Summit
- Housing Economic Summit
- Builder’s Daily Summit
- Webinars
- Demo Day
More +
Welcome,
+
- Your Account
- Manage Feed
- Subscription Options
- Newsletters
- Gift HousingWire
- Podcasts
- Company Search
- Logout
- News+
- Latest News
- Housing Market
- Mortgage
- Mortgage Rates
- Homebuilding
- Reverse
- Real Estate
- Agent
- Brokerage
- Technology
- Title
- Vetted by HW
- Events+
- The Gathering
- AI Summit
- Mortgage Banking Summit
- Housing Economic Summit
- Builder’s Daily Summit
- Webinars
- Demo Day
Subscribe
Sign In
Agent | Contributors | Opinion!Image 4 5 minute read
Why AI is still a subpar real estate agent replacement
AI sits at “remembering,” while top value comes from judgment, negotiation and client trust
April 21, 2026, 4:27pm _by Lee Davenport, Ph.D._
Article Summary
AI can speed up tasks, but it still lacks human judgment, local heuristics, and empathy. The column cites a Florida sale where limited guidance may have cost $75,000 to $225,000 and offers the T.A.P. framework to quantify agent value._AI Summary_
I recently got a question from Real Estate Writer Michele Lerner for _Florida Realtor_magazine that cut right to the chase of this technological moment: Can AI replace real estate agents?
Here’s my answer: Not yet. And maybe not ever, but not because I’m anti-tech. Quite the opposite. I’m an early adopter. I love tools that make us more efficient and informed. Yes, AI is improving every day, but here’s what I also know: there’s a difference between a tool and a trusted, credible advisor (that’s you!).
As of now, AI is as good as the resources it can search and scrub. But information stored in someone’s brain is simply not available for AI to data-mine (yet). I’m talking about unwritten rules of thumb. Heuristic knowledge. Undocumented, insider information and experience from a 20-plus-year pro that can best be learned from a mentor or coach, not AI curation of only existing documents. You know, the “secret sauce.”
The cost of AI being at the bottom of the learning pyramid (for now)
Let me geek out for a bit. There’s this framework called Bloom’s Revised Learning Taxonomy that I reference quite a bit as an MBA professor. Think of it as a pyramid of thinking skills. At the very bottom is _Remembering_,”quickly curating information on a topic. AI is currently great at that base level. No argument from me.
But savvy real estate professionals are still better at the higher functions of that pyramid. _Analyzing_, _evaluating_, and _creating_ positive real estate experiences for homebuyers and home sellers who may only have one or two transactions a decade. This pyramid highlights levels of learning and also the difference between a tool and a strategist.
This matters because moving is often considered one of the top five stressors in life. And often when we are moving, we have another stressor, such as a career change or a household loss (or growth). Thus, for someone who is not a professional real estate investor, this can be a double whammy in regard to stress.
For instance, when my grandmother sold the home that she had raised my mom and her siblings in, after having lived there for 50 years with my granddad (who had passed a couple of years prior), emotionally, that was tough for her. AI could definitely spit out a list of things to do, like “Step one: Declutter. Step two: Cry later,” which feels like what I call AI purgatory. Like me, you may hate AI purgatory, which spits out trite bullet points. Emotionless AI can feel callous and insensitive at times.
But it took human empathy (a function AI has not yet mastered) to help her close that chapter with dignity. Years later, my 97-year-old grandmother still grieves my granddad, that home and our life there. It has only been the human connection that has brought her solace.
As another example, look at what just happened in Cooper City, Fla. A man named Robert Levine used ChatGPT to sell his home. According to Ines Hegedus-Garcia, the buyer’s agent on that deal, the sale shows that while ChatGPT may have helped Levine get to market, it didn’t help him fully capitalize on the multioffer scenario that presented itself. Hegedus-Garcia estimated that the cost of not having experienced, savvy representation likely landed somewhere between $75,000 and $225,000. Yeesh!
That additional step is analyzing, evaluating and creating. That’s the top of Bloom’s learning pyramid.
While we are counting costs, here’s something we don’t talk about enough: AI isn’t free. Not financially, and not environmentally. Every query, every scrape, every model training run requires massive amounts of energy and water. This is a cost to our neighborhoods that may be too expensive to keep paying.
T.A.P. into your value above and beyond AI
I have been successfully coaching agents around the globe for more than a decade with a core strategy called T.A.P. into Your Value, which allows them to thrive despite new tech and trends (remember iBuying?). Here is how it works:
- T is for Tasks (list 100 to 500 things you actually do; just don’t give out any trade secrets!).
- A is for Agenda (how many hours would a non-real estate pro (consumer) waste doing each one?).
- P is for Price (what would a consumer pay out of pocket without your partnerships and inside information?).
For example, verifying a legal address might take you five minutes with your attorney on speed dial, but, even with AI, a consumer could spend hours on sluggish government websites or hundreds of dollars on hourly legal fees just to get started. That is one task on a list of hundreds. When clients see the T.A.P., it becomes painfully obvious that this is a valuable full-time job beyond simply opening a door or generating a task list from AI.
_Dr. Lee Davenport is an MBA graduate school professor, executive business coach, global conference speaker, and author (including Be a Fair Housing D.E.C.O.D.E.R., How to Profit with Your Personality, and over__270 news bylines__or features)._
_This column does not necessarily reflect the opinion of HousingWire’s editorial department and its owners._
_To contact the editor responsible for this piece:tracey@hwmedia.com_
_Related_
16 indispensable AI tools for real estate agentsApril 15, 2026 In "Real Estate"
The 9 best real estate CRMs for every budget in 2026April 16, 2026 In "Real Estate"
Brynn Carmody’s burnout as a real estate agent sparked an AI platform for the entire industryApril 14, 2026 In "Agent"
More:
!Image 7: Lee Davenport, Ph.D.
About Lee Davenport, Ph.D.
Dr. Lee Davenport is the strategic advisor at Real Estate Bees, an MBA graduate school professor, executive business coach, and author (including Be a Fair Housing D.E.C.O.D.E.R. and How to Profit with Your Personality).see full bio
Most Popular Articles
HomeServices of America launches all-in-one real estate solution
The platform combines brokerage mortgage title and insurance services through the company’s network of affiliated businesses.
Mortgage industry welcomes new credit score models, urges further reform
First-time buyers' shrinking presence — what it means for agents
D.R. Horton executed again, and smaller builders feel the squeeze
Tennessee set to legalize proprietary reverse mortgages
NHC urges HUD to withdraw proposed mixed-status eligibility rule
Latest Articles
Home equity emerges as a generational growth strategy for originators
Deephaven’s Tom Davis explains why home equity lending is a generational opportunity and how originators can drive borrower retention and growth.
- Share on X (Opens in new window)X
- Share on Facebook (Opens in new window)Facebook
- Share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)LinkedIn
- Email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)Email
- Click to share on SMS (Opens in new window)SMS
- Click to copy link (Opens in new window)Link Copy
Link Copied
!Image 10: Lee Davenport, Ph.D.
About Lee Davenport, Ph.D.
Dr. Lee Davenport is the strategic advisor at Real Estate Bees, an MBA graduate school professor, executive business coach, and author (including Be a Fair Housing D.E.C.O.D.E.R. and How to Profit with Your Personality).see full bio
Featured Events
-  Hosted By HousingWire Demo Day February Demo Day
-  Hosted By HousingWire Housing Economic Summit 2026
-  Hosted By HousingWire The Gathering 2026
HousingWire Partners
Real Estate Agent Development Plan to Break a Plateau### Home Equity Emerges as a Generational Growth Strategy for Originators### 10 Myths Loan Originators Believe about Reverse Mortgages — and the Reality that Could Change their Business### Here’s How Agentic AI is Already Transforming Title and Escrow
HW Media
Community
Advertise With HW
Company
© 2006-2026 HW Media, LLC. All rights reserved.
Powered by WordPress VIP
What's New?
Updated 15 hours ago
Latest Your Feed
!Image 15: refresh feed
April 25, 2026
Maximize your experience at The Gathering: A blueprint for sessions, networking, and conference strategy
By HW Media Content Studio
Turn The Gathering attendance into ROI. Learn how to maximize your conference with a blueprint for networking, session strategy, and follow-up from HousingWire’s Brena Nath.
April 25, 2026
Home equity emerges as a generational growth strategy for originators
By HW Media Content Studio
Deephaven’s Tom Davis explains why home equity lending is a generational opportunity and how originators can drive borrower retention and growth.
Mortgage
April 24, 2026
How two LOs helped champion proprietary reverse mortgage legislation in Tennessee
By Neil Pierson
Tennessee bill to allow proprietary reverse mortgages expands options beyond HECMs and their $1.25 million limit for 2026.
Legislation Mortgage Reverse
April 24, 2026
Pritzker's honor: Illinois housing reform fight intensifies
By Richard Lawson
Illinois opened hearings on Pritzker’s housing reform bills, aiming to expand by-right density as cities argue for opt-in rules.
April 24, 2026
PulteGroup targets margin stability through an upward mix shift
By Tyler Williams
PulteGroup's Q1 2026 ASP fell 5% to $542,000, incentives rose to 10.9%, and gross margin declined to 24.4%.
April 24, 2026
Meritage Q1 2026 shows why incentives are the new battlefield
By John McManus
Meritage Q1 2026 saw orders down 5% and gross margin at 17.5%, as incentives rose and earnings per share fell 51%.
April 24, 2026
First-time homebuyers' shrinking presence — what it means for real estate agents
By Jonathan Delozier
The trends is reshaping how agents build their businesses, talk about value and prepare for a future without traditional buyer pipelines.
Agent Real Estate
April 24, 2026
NYC launches new unit to combat deed theft
By HousingWire Automation
NYC formed an Office of Deed Theft Prevention to flag suspicious filings, support homeowners and coordinate law enforcement responses.
Regulatory Title
April 24, 2026
SoFi rolls out end-to-end digital HELOC experience, advisory council
By Sarah Wolak
SoFi unveiled an end-to-end digital HELOC and a 50-member advisory council as homeowners aim to keep 2% to 3% mortgages.
Mortgage Origination
April 24, 2026
Powell is done. Will Warsh help with mortgage rates?
By Logan Mohtashami
DOJ ended its Fed probe, boosting Warsh odds, but mortgage rates still track the 10-year yield, forecast at 3.80% to 4.60% in 2026.
Mortgage Mortgage Rates Regulatory
April 24, 2026
Coldwell Banker: ‘Life doesn’t stop’ as comeback buyers return
By Jonathan Delozier
For many, the decision to list is no longer about timing. It's about necessity, said Coldwell Banker Affiliates President Jason Waugh.
Agent Brokerage Real Estate
April 24, 2026
Freddie Mac securitizes first wave of Newrez mortgages with VantageScore 4.0
By Flávia Furlan Nunes and HousingWire Automation
Freddie Mac securitized Newrez mortgages scored with VantageScore 4.0, as FHFA rolls out a limited lender pilot using modern credit scores.
Mortgage Regulatory
April 24, 2026
Did HUD, FHFA push homebuying into a new era with credit score advancements?
By Jennifer McGuinness
HUD and FHFA will accept FICO 10T and VantageScore 4.0, but LLPA grids, securitization demands and tech work drive timing.
Mortgage Regulatory
April 24, 2026
Bess Freedman: It's time to call out the facts around private listing networks
By Bess Freedman
A real estate CEO argues private listing networks limit exposure, reduce price discovery, and hide days on market and price cuts for buyers.
Brokerage Opinion Real Estate
April 24, 2026
States' deed theft protection measures tracked by new tool
By HousingWire Automation
The tool classifies each jurisdiction on a five-tier framework ranging from enacted law with criminal penalties to no legislative action.
Real Estate Title
April 24, 2026
How top agents set the tone in the first 15 minutes
By Juliet Clapp
Top agents prioritize listening over pitching, ask better questions, clarify the process, and adjust to client cues in minutes.
Agent Opinion Real Estate
April 24, 2026
Brands by Integra enters Arizona through partnership with Phoenix brokerage CITIEA
By HousingWire Automation
Brands by Integra enters Arizona via CITIEA partnership, tying regional expansion to 72SOLD and Homes2X listing demand.
Brokerage Real Estate
April 24, 2026
Citizens: Homeowners shift toward a ‘stay and upgrade’ mindset
By Sarah Wolak
Citizens finds 71% plan renovations in two years, 63% may need financing in five years, and 39% do not understand their options.
Housing Market Mortgage
April 24, 2026
ICE First Look shows mortgage delinquencies fall in March 2026
By HousingWire Automation
ICE said delinquencies fell to 3.35% in March 2026, while SMM rose to 1.06% and foreclosure inventory hit 273,000 loans.
Data & Visuals Mortgage
April 24, 2026
DOJ drops probe tied to Fed, potentially easing path for Warsh confirmation
By Flávia Furlan Nunes
DOJ closed its Jerome Powell probe and referred the Fed HQ renovation to the inspector general as Kevin Warsh’s confirmation odds rose.
Mortgage Regulatory
See what’s happening in your market
Select a zip code to view market data, or leave blank to see national trends.
Location:
Save Preferences
[](https://www.housingwire.com/articles/why-ai-is-still-a-subpar-real-estate-agent-replacement/#)
[](https://www.housingwire.com/articles/why-ai-is-still-a-subpar-real-estate-agent-replacement/#)